3515 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214

The Supply Closet

recycled craft supplies donation pay as you wish

Whether it’s leftover materials from a brief foray into macramé or never opened goods from an unrealized fantasy of becoming a wood burner extraordinaire, most crafters have a giant stash of craft supplies that will never be used again. The Supply Closet at Wholly Craft helps bring these supplies back to life and get them into the hands of other makers who will put them to use.

The Supply Closet is a recycled craft supply resource accepting donations of gently used craft supplies including yarn, fabric, ribbon, jewelry making tools, paper craft supplies, and instructional books. These materials are sorted, merchandised, and made available at pay-as-you-wish pricing. Visitors to the Supply Closet inside Wholly Craft can name their own price for individual supplies or pick up a basketful of supplies for $10. Proceeds from the Supply Closet support free kids craft programming and a portion of every sale benefits Women Crafting Change.

Donations are accepted anytime during store hours. If you have an extra large donation (like a full car load), please email or call ahead so we can prepare some space. Want to know if you can donate macramé cord and wood burning tools?  Please check out our Donation Wish List below!

The Supply Closet is open during regular store hours but closed during special events like workshops and birthday parties. If you're making a special trip just to shop the Supply Closet, please email or call ahead to make sure it's open.



Embroidery thread, crewel threads, sewing and serger threads, needles, scissors, rotary cutters/mats, rulers, buttons, fasteners, elastic, binding, ribbon, ric-rac, lace, natural or synthetic fabrics (at least 1/4 yard), vintage linens, interfacing, poly-fil, pillow forms, quilting supplies, quilt blocks


Any yarns (natural, synthetic, blends, novelty), roving for spinning/felting, natural/nylon rope, jute/hemp for macrame, knitting needles/accessories, embroidery hoops/needles/patterns, needle felting supplies, fiber spinning/weaving tools


Charms, beads, gemstones, jewelry string, wire, chain, findings, tools


Scissors, punches, stamps, stickers, tapes, glues, ink pads/bottles, marking/calligraphy pens, paper goods such as maps, vintage postcards, origami paper, scrapbooking papers, cardstock, paper bags, magazines from 1970s or older, vintage illustrated books, old black and white photos, sheet music


Art/craft acrylics, oils and mediums, paint brushes, canvases/drawing papers, pencils/pens/markers, pastels, polymer clay, sculpting tools and mediums, glues, adhesives, glitter, sequins, patches, craft/floral styrofoam, pipe cleaners, feathers, googly eyes, craft felt

* Items we cannot accept include:

Sewing machines, clothing (cut up or intact), fabric scraps, post-consumer waste (egg cartons, pill bottles, etc.) UFOs (unfinished objects)


Join our Mailing List

Sign up to receive our daily email and get 50% off your first purchase.